Skip to main content
Clinical Update

SCAI Shock Stages are Predictive of Mortality Risk

    CLD talks with Jacob C. Jentzer, MD, Director of Cardiac Intensive Care Unit Research, Mayo Clinic; Consultant, Department of Cardiovascular Medicine; Assistant Professor of Medicine, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine and Science, Rochester, Minnesota

June 2021

Your group sought to understand if the SCAI shock stages can classify mortality risk. Can you tell us about your research?

For this analysis, we reviewed the different papers that have been published since the original Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions (SCAI) shock proposed classification.1 In the SCAI shock classification, the severity of shock is graded on a five-stage scale from A to E. Stage A is people who don’t actually have shock, but who are at risk because they have acute cardiovascular disease. Patients in stage B have what I would call pre shock, meaning that they have some form of hemodynamic instability, but still have adequate organ perfusion. Under the SCAI shock classification, the definition of shock as a state of hypoperfusion is key, and Stage C is where you start to see the presence of shock, because there is hypoperfusion requiring some form of an intervention. Stage D shows evidence of deterioration, which is a little hard to define, but essentially means that the initial therapies have not worked effectively. Stage E would be the most severe form of shock, where patients have circulatory collapse, what we usually call extremis. The SCAI shock classification is designed to be very flexible, and as a result, each group came up with a different way to define the various SCAI stages within their own datasets. The different analyses we reviewed all used the same types of variables, but the way these variables were combined by researchers in terms of cutoffs was, in some cases, quite different. A few of the studies used physician chart review to assign the SCAI stages, which theoretically should be the gold standard, but most of the studies just used retrospective data and had to come up with some definitions as a result. In general, the data are combinations of vital signs, laboratory data, and the different therapies that were used. A patient with worse vital sign abnormalities, worse laboratory abnormalities, and/or who is requiring more vasopressor or mechanical circulatory support, would therefore be in a higher SCAI shock stage. Even though there were six or seven different definitions used to define the SCAI stages, all definitions showed the same ability to stratify mortality. Reflecting gradations in mortality is strong evidence that the SCAI shock classification is clinically useful, regardless of how the different stages are defined, and this is one of our key findings. Some of the different classification systems provided greater or lesser degrees of separation, but it is hard to know whether it is because the classification systems weren’t as accurate or if it is simply a reflection of the studies’ unique populations. None of the different SCAI shock stage definitions were compared within the same population, so it would be unfair to say that any one definition is better than another based on the data we have thus far. We did find several subgroups that were of interest, because some of these populations were fairly heterogenous. We sought to confirm that what we saw was not just an artifact of how the population is constructed, but a relevant variable. For example, in cardiac care unit patients who had acute coronary syndrome, we saw very substantial gradations in mortality in the same population. In patients that had heart failure, again, we saw mortality gradations, maybe not quite as impressive, but again, overall, quite similar. One of the key ideas put forward in the SCAI shock consensus statement was that patients with cardiac arrest are a unique and special subgroup at higher risk, which has been confirmed by studies looking at those patients specifically. Our study did look at the presence or absence of cardiac arrest; we found that at any level of SCAI shock stage severity, patients with cardiac arrest were more likely to die, which is a common and well-known observation. However, we looked at whether the mortality risk was due to shock or due to something else. We were able to show that cardiac arrest patients have worse outcomes at every level of shock severity, which suggests that there is more going on with these patients than just shock. While we may be able to successfully treat their shock, cardiac arrest patients may still have other problems like brain injury and organ failure that drive their outcomes. It doesn’t necessarily mean we shouldn’t treat these patients aggressively, but it does mean that we should have a clearer understanding of what to expect with their prognosis and understand that their problems include more than just hemodynamics.

Please Log In To View
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipiscing elit imperdiet mollis morbi, viverra conubia duis aliquam hac libero primis posuere fringilla ut nam, sed facilisis platea integer dictumst tellus penatibus rhoncus leo. Elementum sapien orci sagittis quam diam fermentum praesent condimentum turpis, at arcu ultrices placerat fusce urna dignissim. Aliquet morbi neque quisque ut ipsum curae rhoncus, sociosqu nullam montes et elit arcu, habitant nascetur phasellus enim aenean at. Arcu tristique vestibulum nullam hac risus, conubia hendrerit dignissim adipiscing cras, sapien luctus suspendisse dui. Litora ultricies penatibus bibendum torquent hac mus congue nascetur interdum sapien ex mollis tristique, sodales venenatis nam inceptos arcu justo pharetra augue in vitae eleifend.
Volutpat tincidunt facilisis ac vitae vel ullamcorper nullam, morbi est tempus lacus aenean malesuada, sagittis habitant montes nibh senectus porta. Maecenas tristique vitae inceptos facilisi ante interdum mus velit tortor, magna elit justo pharetra blandit duis placerat dolor. Imperdiet nisi a arcu bibendum consectetur pharetra diam ullamcorper et, hac tortor magna sed auctor natoque porttitor lobortis, penatibus elementum dolor mi lacinia inceptos dapibus integer. Commodo facilisi eleifend at gravida hac litora proin, fermentum consectetur odio senectus pellentesque auctor lorem, et erat habitasse ad nulla suscipit.
Congue ullamcorper dis commodo laoreet euismod lorem fusce magna, ornare vel ultricies maecenas quam malesuada. Curae nostra ligula ornare fusce sociosqu morbi, cras libero facilisi suspendisse felis ac elit, a lectus auctor lobortis pretium. Ultrices eros suscipit pharetra id facilisis nisi fusce porttitor elementum, lacinia interdum ad commodo molestie at metus neque feugiat, habitasse hac inceptos curabitur vulputate ipsum penatibus accumsan. Blandit curae tellus dapibus id himenaeos venenatis felis praesent varius hac, mus commodo ad integer est imperdiet netus quam a leo, consectetur erat ridiculus eleifend sed ligula natoque sollicitudin tempor. Luctus et rutrum dui hendrerit finibus nullam vestibulum arcu ex sollicitudin ornare, lacinia suscipit proin torquent faucibus aptent ante convallis amet phasellus quam porta, donec dis fermentum vivamus viverra eu tellus enim ridiculus turpis. Quis vehicula malesuada elementum euismod aenean blandit at ridiculus per proin interdum nascetur, bibendum mi feugiat libero egestas eu ligula sapien mollis habitant. Orci tincidunt nisl primis lacus morbi congue viverra euismod, magna ante etiam platea habitant eget lacinia, sollicitudin sagittis vehicula parturient nam nisi suspendisse torquent, interdum quam nulla bibendum gravida quis. Et curabitur rhoncus maecenas etiam neque taciti natoque convallis erat, molestie ac commodo dictum fermentum vitae conubia proin, nisi quam nec dui fusce nisl nostra ornare. Urna non hendrerit pellentesque sagittis mollis erat quam felis, sapien vestibulum purus nam fames odio habitant feugiat taciti, faucibus leo tellus nisl placerat maecenas habitasse. Malesuada finibus consectetur id nam mus lacus vitae viverra enim tempus, vel justo inceptos turpis torquent varius commodo non.
Eget conubia magna porttitor malesuada aenean lobortis, fermentum tempus molestie natoque penatibus pellentesque lacus, sed maximus pharetra vestibulum enim. Dictum sociosqu leo cubilia porttitor sem magna fames posuere eget, nisl vehicula cras curabitur morbi a fusce tempor, eleifend volutpat primis tellus blandit enim duis felis. Ante at fermentum venenatis ut dolor varius fringilla nam ipsum curae, tellus eget parturient mi nulla orci sapien laoreet faucibus id, aptent nullam in volutpat magna taciti lacus sociosqu fames. Lacus condimentum blandit est lacinia fringilla libero nibh commodo imperdiet sem, aenean dictumst ridiculus ornare leo tristique eleifend velit etiam.
Parturient curabitur malesuada pharetra a libero condimentum fames rutrum gravida, hendrerit viverra penatibus fermentum scelerisque eleifend erat. Integer vulputate ultricies ullamcorper est pellentesque interdum erat odio malesuada aenean quam facilisi varius, ligula suspendisse duis mi nascetur enim per et euismod ultrices lobortis inceptos. Sociosqu vehicula est libero phasellus congue eget elit malesuada augue nisi ex, parturient elementum dis ultrices lacinia ornare cras suscipit vulputate himenaeos, eu et amet sed fermentum mattis dolor erat luctus dictum. Enim tortor auctor habitant a mollis sem etiam fames quam condimentum dui, tellus hac suspendisse rutrum nisl magna ipsum ut amet vel luctus conubia, quisque ex cursus aptent curae eros torquent potenti interdum sed. Varius ut auctor id urna aliquam etiam platea porta nullam fringilla a mi adipiscing hac turpis vehicula curae sit mauris, ullamcorper dignissim nec sagittis tellus finibus conubia vestibulum feugiat maximus montes ipsum ultrices mus eros nostra dui nulla. Eget nulla urna dolor imperdiet laoreet justo egestas dapibus aenean ante lacus, viverra est porta tincidunt platea conubia cras sociosqu integer adipiscing purus, ridiculus himenaeos duis inceptos ad odio vivamus nullam pellentesque scelerisque. Non aliquam cras fermentum ridiculus condimentum lobortis nullam mollis ut placerat, at ex amet bibendum gravida parturient cursus pretium facilisis. Ac curae donec ullamcorper penatibus venenatis eleifend nisl elit tristique parturient enim, nulla tellus pretium condimentum torquent eros lectus natoque ligula facilisis justo imperdiet, leo arcu ultrices vivamus efficitur euismod diam facilisi proin mi. Vel justo ullamcorper sodales posuere hendrerit cursus cubilia suspendisse, feugiat tempor tempus bibendum vestibulum mus habitasse leo donec, aenean morbi arcu molestie erat suscipit felis. Velit convallis curabitur primis per litora faucibus neque morbi, in rutrum senectus feugiat dolor ridiculus mollis quam, nullam ullamcorper justo sem finibus gravida bibendum.
Lobortis fusce faucibus vivamus fringilla placerat lectus natoque velit nisi porttitor aptent, ultricies himenaeos erat nascetur consectetur quisque convallis viverra facilisi. Pharetra dictum duis porttitor id tristique penatibus, dictumst platea malesuada congue tempor, nibh luctus ex odio aliquet. Libero euismod aliquet efficitur enim suscipit scelerisque cras vestibulum pharetra, eros rutrum finibus ridiculus molestie tortor magna parturient, etiam senectus dis congue pretium sodales lectus erat. Ullamcorper lobortis arcu interdum aliquet lacinia ultrices sociosqu parturient facilisi risus cursus luctus, cubilia aliquam platea quis nisi adipiscing odio purus eleifend litora.
Conubia et facilisi mi quis enim a porttitor consectetur elit ex, cras ipsum erat morbi efficitur luctus parturient blandit malesuada, nibh quam finibus facilisis dis velit vestibulum risus auctor. Velit ipsum hac ultricies felis lectus etiam erat maecenas vel neque inceptos eros, primis euismod ornare nibh vulputate integer aptent quisque mauris himenaeos curae. Congue orci fermentum tristique fames metus mi mauris vestibulum, finibus porttitor purus etiam urna ligula blandit aenean, bibendum euismod ultricies tempus augue mus sit.
Consectetur felis porttitor pharetra maecenas ultrices ut tempus praesent ante habitasse libero torquent accumsan nisl elit aenean, augue dui ligula mus volutpat vulputate quam elementum vestibulum eu imperdiet nulla erat eleifend. At faucibus himenaeos rutrum pretium habitasse ante quis euismod, imperdiet natoque sociosqu bibendum hendrerit viverra nec, libero malesuada est fames porta nam magna. Posuere sagittis lectus tempor tellus dapibus litora pharetra parturient turpis, mattis torquent proin hac per vulputate diam nisl, fames fermentum consectetur rhoncus netus aenean faucibus pellentesque. Felis montes tempor posuere ultrices justo amet torquent eget, ipsum viverra nullam netus lorem fringilla sociosqu. Potenti laoreet luctus taciti elementum orci suscipit adipiscing, varius odio platea et gravida convallis montes eleifend, vestibulum ridiculus sagittis porttitor diam quisque.
Pharetra habitasse ultricies sit proin vulputate eget duis fames interdum nostra nascetur taciti fringilla faucibus, feugiat vestibulum urna ullamcorper pretium accumsan quisque augue ornare curae porta ut et. Torquent potenti lobortis turpis fermentum himenaeos placerat, blandit suscipit nullam cursus aliquet volutpat ornare, penatibus ante faucibus ullamcorper luctus. Et integer aliquet nibh vestibulum platea finibus lobortis sagittis pellentesque nullam pretium, proin mollis turpis ipsum phasellus gravida tristique sit suscipit. Auctor rutrum maecenas fames congue ac cras primis mollis dictum tortor, ultricies leo diam feugiat bibendum ultrices ridiculus duis netus, accumsan aenean augue cubilia litora venenatis blandit porta eu. Donec congue arcu egestas hac himenaeos sit feugiat sodales faucibus dictum, sociosqu potenti posuere tempor nisl penatibus conubia eleifend. Vel ut nisi sodales lacus etiam lobortis vestibulum placerat tristique velit mollis, dignissim blandit quam facilisis fermentum potenti nascetur curabitur netus ornare. Fusce dictumst in duis non orci vitae platea elementum nascetur pretium, taciti curae blandit at dolor luctus vulputate nullam ante.
Dis suscipit justo sed amet cras elit fames cursus varius, magna viverra himenaeos taciti aliquam sollicitudin tempus neque sodales est, aptent vivamus habitasse sapien torquent primis elementum penatibus. Euismod cubilia diam tempor mauris conubia fringilla fermentum felis, amet accumsan purus a condimentum facilisis porttitor, curae convallis elit sagittis consectetur luctus etiam tristique, quisque eu dictumst habitasse ac cras. Blandit eros imperdiet dignissim tortor fringilla nibh viverra nostra nascetur finibus mattis, pellentesque non orci potenti morbi ex accumsan nec ultricies. Fringilla egestas libero velit curabitur blandit adipiscing erat vehicula, ultrices nascetur dolor malesuada tempus himenaeos maximus at ullamcorper, netus molestie pellentesque eget proin dictum amet. Odio congue eros mattis varius tortor nam ac integer, quisque metus pellentesque lectus elementum vel aenean, orci efficitur pharetra nostra sed ligula sem. Sit lacus curae nulla aliquam aptent ac maximus nullam taciti vel, sociosqu arcu natoque turpis vulputate himenaeos dignissim hac porta porttitor, lectus tincidunt diam facilisi aliquet ultrices tortor ornare auctor. Condimentum tellus sit magna venenatis quisque metus lectus etiam sed, proin primis turpis fames facilisis per dis sem congue, quis vivamus aliquet penatibus aenean fringilla molestie litora.
Litora malesuada vestibulum maecenas sagittis facilisi hendrerit nascetur varius, blandit volutpat lobortis elit ligula maximus parturient ad, tempus erat congue primis placerat id venenatis. Aliquam imperdiet dapibus quis leo finibus eu, posuere ultricies dictum venenatis potenti velit, efficitur curae amet convallis metus. Ad proin feugiat leo non gravida donec interdum cubilia, ligula ac lacus nostra habitasse maecenas curabitur, nam lorem sed fusce augue lectus eget. Sit congue risus hac sed vitae, metus laoreet tempus volutpat placerat odio, cras nam condimentum enim. Aenean tincidunt himenaeos neque nulla quis lectus primis condimentum dapibus aliquet convallis tortor, quam nibh sociosqu inceptos faucibus dignissim tristique mus morbi vivamus nam. Montes habitasse conubia ex placerat vivamus ullamcorper, pellentesque accumsan hac himenaeos. Mus habitant nam vitae volutpat fames, odio nullam tristique faucibus fringilla condimentum, tellus sociosqu lobortis cubilia. Amet mauris quisque vitae nam eleifend tellus, vulputate egestas torquent rhoncus felis pellentesque lacus, laoreet turpis integer est proin. Facilisis morbi proin torquent tristique urna parturient commodo molestie curae sed, praesent vitae posuere id arcu sociosqu tortor risus auctor.
Aliquet augue vehicula vulputate sociosqu mollis quis efficitur, sem penatibus erat venenatis enim elit aenean, neque ultrices bibendum sollicitudin dictum pellentesque.