Inefficient Administrative Processes Associated With Inappropriate Denials or Care Delays Among MA Organizations
Key Takeaways:
- In an analysis of Medicare Advantage organization (MAO) violations, one-third involved inappropriate denials or delays of care, with most violations relating to Part D medications.
- The monetary penalties associated with inappropriate denials or delays of care violations totaled to $616 366.
- The most common causes of violations were workflow deficiencies and staff mistakes, highlighting the need for more efficient administrative procedures.
MAOs tend to implement utilization management policies such as prior authorization (PA) to manage health care spending. However, reliance on PA may delay or deny medically necessary care, as 7.7% of 2024 MA PA requests were denied.
While the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) regularly audits MAO operating practices, information regarding resulting violations and enforcement is limited.
Study Methods and Outcomes
Researchers assessed CMS enforcement actions between September 2021 and February 2026 to characterize MAO violations, particularly those associated with inappropriate denials or delays of care.
All identified enforcement actions were broken into 4 groups:
- Inappropriate denials or delays of care or medications
- Errors in premium, cost-sharing, and out-of-pocket (OOP) maximum
- Low star ratings
- Other violations
Researchers determined the resulting monetary penalties associated with each violation type. In addition, a qualitative content analysis was conducted to identify themes, subthemes, and patterns among inappropriate denials or delays, as well as the frequency of each subtheme.
Penalties and Underlying Factors Associated MAO Violations
The study identified 66 violations that resulted in CMS enforcement, 22 (33.3%) of which were categorized as inappropriate denials or delays of care. Most (16) of these violations involved Part D medications, and 4 involved Part C services.
The associated monetary penalties for group 1 violations amounted to $616 366. For groups 2 and 4, the median penalty amounts were $33 988 and $47 596, respectively.
The qualitative content analysis identified 2 main themes: types of violations and underlying causes.
Among the main types of violations, the most common were inappropriately rejected or administered formulary medications (9 violations) and inappropriately denied or processed coverage requests, determinations, or complaints (7 violations).
The most common underlying causes included internal procedural or workflow deficiencies (7 violations), staff mistakes (5 violations), and incorrect data used for plan enrollment (4 violations).
Implications for Managed Care
These findings reveal insufficiencies within MAO operational workflows, as violations related to inappropriate denials or delays of care were most caused by procedural deficiencies and human errors. Streamlining administrative processes may reduce system complexity and improve care delivery among MA beneficiaries.
Because CMS audits assess procedural adherence, researchers could not identify denials based on medical necessity or determine the number of beneficiaries impacted by each violation.
The authors concluded, “This study found that MAOs only received CMS sanctions for inappropriate denials or delays of care due to nonadherence to procedural requirements rather than explicit determinations of medical necessity.”
Reference
Chen Z, Gadbois EA, Meyers DJ, Marr J, Dixit MN, Trivedi AN. Inappropriate denials or delays of care or medications by Medicare Advantage organizations. JAMA Health Forum. 2026;7(10):e264015. doi:10.1001/jamahealthforum.2026.4015


